Molly writes scripts for romantic comedies, so she is convinced that true love is a myth invented for films and books. Her stories are successful, and her heart is impregnable. Seth is convinced that love can overcome any obstacles and believes in love and romance, even though he works as one of Chicago's top divorce lawyers. They used to be in the same class and even dated, but Molly ‘dumped’ him just before graduation, breaking his heart. Seth didn't have time to find out why. After 15 years, he finally gets the chance to do so at the reunion...